GIVEAWAY WINNER: Taylor Earnshaw is the winner of the free ticket to my first planning class! Yay! You can buy tickets here or fill out the Google Form to receive updates about future classes/the e-course in this post. Thanks!

I’ve been thinking about baby products so much as I prepare for my second baby and watch several friends who are pregnant for the first time. It’s a jungle out there. We are so incredibly blessed to live in an internet era where we can google any questions, crowd-source opinions about theories and techniques, and find product descriptions and reviews that are helpful to us. I don’t know how our moms did it, to be honest. It’s crazy how much I’ve used the internet in the 21 months Reese has been with us (and the 9 months of pregnancy before that lol).

The problem with it is twofold, in my opinion.

1. There is just TOO MUCH. Too many options. It’s so easy to get overwhelmed and paralyzed by choice. It’s great, of course, because the likelihood of your particular needs being met by a product are high. But knowing your needs and knowing which products will meet them is so difficult, and this is not a situation that needs more complication or stress.
2. Everything is Capitalism – even the mommy bloggers you trust the most. This isn’t really that ~bad. People gotta eat, man! Products must be sold! But sometimes companies/bloggers/advertisers will prey on the stress and earnest desires of first time moms to have and be and deliver the very best for their babies. I’ve got news for you: sometimes bloggers will promote an item they don’t actually use or don’t really like just because they got paid a lot to do so. And guess what? Sometimes they’ll promote an item they ABSOLUTELY LOVE! But it’s super expensive and they got it for free. Or they might be genuinely sharing a product they bought themselves and used free of sponsorship. Sometimes you don’t know.

Here’s what I’m saying: You don’t always know what you need, or what you want, or what will work for you. That doesn’t mean you need to buy everything that The Baby Cubby posts about or each product your favorite mommy blogger shares. I’ve fallen for this, and it’s ok if you have too. It isn’t the end of the world if you buy a product you don’t actually like.

But if your budget is tight, or you notice yourself feeling mom guilt or an urge to buy every fancy or cool gadget you see on Instagram… it’s important to stop and say: “Wait. Do I REALLY need this? Does baby really need this? Or am I just buying it because it’s cute/cool/trendy?” I have to ask myself this all the time. Well, actually, it’s The Beard asking me that all the time, which in turn reminds me to think about it myself.

Today I’m teaming up with one of my chicest and smartest mom friends to talk about the stuff we have found we actually NEED and the stuff that looks trendy and necessary… but you actually DON’T need. Jess is up first! (More about her and her cute family on her blog.)

**REMINDER** This is OPINION HOMIES. If you disagree – that’s a-ok! We’re all allowed to think what we want to think! Go read another blog! This is based on our opinions and experience. It’s cool if yours are different. Good for you! Good for all of us!

JESS

I wouldn’t say I’m a veteran mom, but this definitely isn’t my first rodeo. As such, I’ve pretty much figured out what our “baby essentials” are. There are LOADS of blogs, pregnancy apps, and boutique shops that will tell you what you ~MUST~ have to “make those first months wonderful” and I kinda call BS on most of it. When we had Milo, we were poor college students living in a 2 bedroom, 900 square foot pioneer house. There was no way he was getting his own little nursery. I used to feel bad about that but then I realized maybe it was a good idea to not set that precedent for ourselves. Really, does your baby care what color his bedroom walls are painted? And honestly, who really has all the money laying around to go out and buy all these high-end products when there a loads of cheaper options? Babies really have very few needs: food, clothes, a place to sleep, diapers & wipes, and a carseat.

When pregnant with Milo, I was really adamant that we didn’t buy anything that was gendered in case our next was a girl. In fact, we didn’t reveal his gender for this reason. Practically, this would save us from having to buy an all new wardrobe but also, I just really don’t like pink frilly bows haha. This turned out to be a lifesaver for us because I ended up not needing a single thing when Livvy came around. Sure, we got girl clothes from baby showers for her, and I did go slightly nuts with hair bows I actually liked, but we were pretty set!

So, all that said, below are my top 5 baby necessities, and top 5 baby “unnecessities.”

Necessary

1. Fisher Price Rock n’ Play – We got this as a baby shower gift with Milo from my aunt who had also used it. In our tiny house, we didn’t have room for a full on crib in our bedroom, but I wanted Milo to sleep close to me while he was nursing at night. This Rock n’ Play is incredible for small spaces! It folds up easily and is very portable and is very light. We’ve used it with both kids for the first 4-6 months of life. It also is slightly reclined, which was perfect for Livvy as she dealt with acid reflux & colic; being reclined helped keep the acid down. Ours also vibrates if we want (neither kid loved that), and it does rock. When sleep training our kids, if they woke up slightly fussy, I’d gently rock them back to sleep. Another huge plus for us was it’s portability as we’d take it to grandma’s house if we were there for an extended stay. The newer version is self-rocking which we’re probably gonna get for this baby as ours has seen better days. Like I said, we used it 4 times a day, for a total of 16 months! 
   1. Danica’s Note: Yes. Some type of small swing/bouncer is vital. I was lucky and my amazing parents got us a MamaRoo for Christmas and we loved it. But you don’t ~need an expensive one. Just a landing zone that preferably bounces/vibrates/rocks/something will work.
2. Pamper’s Diapers – We’re huge Pamper’s fans over here. We’ve tried Huggies and the Costco/Kirkland brand, but for whatever reason both kinds disintegrated off our kids’ bums. I like the idea of the Honest Company kind, but they’re too expensive for how many we go through and honestly? They just get pooped in anyway! We use Amazon Prime for our diaper orders and save about $20 total for a huge box of size 4’s & 5’s. Pamper’s ARE more expensive, but my logic is I’d rather pay a bit more for diapers that hold up because one awful blowout can ruin a full outfit and blanket, and could mean loads of carseat or crib cleaning.
   1. Danica’s Note: Reese was a blowout baby and I can tell you that paying for a nicer diaper is WORTHHHHHHHHH it, especially if your kid is talented in the diaper department. It saves you on extra diapers, laundry, and just plain sanity. We did mostly Huggies & Pampers, and now that Reese isn’t blowing out we can do store-brand cheap ones.
3. Carseat – I honestly think this mostly comes down to personal preference. All carseats are put through rigorous testing before being allowed out into production. Some may have slightly higher safety ratings, but it’s pretty negligible. The only REAL thing you need to pay attention too is the expiration date, and, if you’re buying it secondhand, if it’s ever been in a car accident before. We got the Chicco Keyfit 30 carseat (and by “got”, I mean we were given). I personally liked the easy “click” function into the car seat base. We’ve been perfectly happy with it.
   • Strollers – I’ll mention this here, although it’s technically not a baby “necessity” within the first few months. Many car seats have a compatible stroller. We requested the matching stroller as our big ticket baby shower item with Milo, but I honestly didn’t get much use from it until Milo was 6ish months old. Depending on the time of year you have your baby, a stroller may not be a huge deal for you, although it’s good to keep in mind when buying a carseat.
4. Puj Tub – We didn’t have this with Milo, but I so wish we did! I found it on a garage sale site for like, $10, a few days before I had Livvy and MAN ALIVE. What a great invention. We usually bathe our newborns once every other day but the newborn blowouts are inevitable. This little invention made those blowouts much easier to handle. We stored it in the 1 inch gap between our bathroom sink and the wall – I say that to emphasize how space friendly it is. It seems like a lot of money for just a baby tub but we got a TON of use out of it with just one baby, and I know we will with this next one.
   1. Danica’s Note: Yep. Totally worth it, love it, amazing.
5. Clothes storage option – Obviously most people assume this means a dresser. I wasn’t too worried about having enough clothes for either kid. I’m pretty prolific in finding great sales and we were given quite a few pieces. However the STORAGE option can get really expensive if you’re not careful. We opted for just a basic Ikea dresser; my hope is that these will grow with each kid. We couldn’t afford a high-end dresser, plus we didn’t really think it was all that prudent, but we also didn’t want something that would break within the first three uses either. We also had the space for a decent sized dresser. So this dresser worked perfect for us. I have seen LOADS of clothes storage options though for all different price ranges and available spaces. A friend of mine used a plastic craft drawer option and hung dresses on a rod above that. It cost her $30 and was maybe 2 feet wide and 4 feet tall. If you’re struggling for ideas, Pinterest and Google are great go-to’s!
   1. Reese’s nursery is tiny, so I used cute fabric buckets in bookshelves and a hanging organizer in the closet! I think I probably spent less than $50 on the entire clothing organization, but having something to store tiny clothes in an organized way is critical.

Unnecessary

1. Baby bottle dryer – This thing makes me laugh nearly every time I see it. You could just use a dish towel and tilt the bottle so air can get into it, or stick em in the dishwasher 😉
2. Baby food blender – In another life, we would’ve just called this a blender. We had a Ninja blender that worked just fine for making baby food, if that’s your thing.
3. Baby toys – this will be an eventual “need”, but your new baby is not gonna have any interest in toys for quite a while. Even then, the toys you get them will never be as interesting as the packaging they come in. I’m honestly considering getting our kids their own set of Tupperware for Christmas and that’s about it.
   1. Danica’s Note: Agree 100%. The only exception I’d make is some type of hanging toy/mobile for the carseat if they struggle in the car. But those are cheap and do NOT need to be fancy.
4. A designer diaper bag – I know there are mixed feelings about this. My personal preference was to have a bag big enough to hold what I needed, but I really wanted to avoid a bag that looked like a diaper bag. I could easily have spent $200+ for a bag like this, but the only way I could really justify that amount of money is if the bag actually changed the diapers too 😉 I first got a shoulder strap kind by Skip Hop called the Versa bag as a baby shower gift. I really loved it, but quickly realized that with two kids, I’d need both hands free. I then got the Forma Diaper bag (also by SkipHop) and I’ve loved it. SkipHop has a lifetime warranty on their products so it was worth the money for me. If you’re tight on cash though, honestly a big purse or a normal backpack works just fine too.
   1. Danica’s Note: Honestly, probably the dumbest purchase I made was a Petunia Picklebottom. Don’t get me wrong – they’re incredible! But very expensive. You don’t need one. Honestly a big enough purse or backpack works great! I used a leather tote from Target for a long time. Nbd.
5. Baby shoes – I know they’re adorable. I know it sounds like a good idea. Truly though, your new baby has absolutely no use for shoes. Livvy lived in footed pj’s or socks with some hand knit booties my aunt gave me (she’s an October baby); Milo didn’t need socks as a July baby. Around 6 months they discover their feet and everything comes off anyway. Livvy is BARELY balancing on her feet now, at a year old, and she just takes her shoes of asap. Moccasins are WAY, way cute, but they aren’t necessary.
   1. Danica’s Note: AMENNNNNNNNN. Chill out with the Freshly Picked moccasins.

I think in general the rule to keep in mind is whether you’re actually shopping for you or for the baby. While I’d love to dress my kids in BabyGap from head to toe, financially that just isn’t reasonable. Moreover, your kids really just don’t care what they’re wearing. I’ve found once I can clearly evaluate what my kid actually needs versus what I think they need, I’m better able to find cheaper, more practical options!

DANICA

Necessary

1. Nursing Pillow – (above) even if you’re not going to nurse I used it constantly. Some people say like “Oh don’t let your kid sleep/lay on the nursing pillow!!!” but honestly it worked great for us. She’d take naps in it as a newborn, and eventually when she was learning to sit up we propped it around her perfectly. I registered for a plain Boppy for my shower and then bought a cute cover for it and I have to say – definitely worth it. I did also buy 2 of these cheaper, knockoff types (they always do deals or you can get coupon codes for everything but shipping) and they’ll do as well. They’re thinner and not as sturdy, but since my home is 2 levels it was really nice to have one in each space I nursed without having to carry them around.
   1. Jessica’s Note: I would’ve died without my nursing pillow my first time going through that! Not just for nursing, but also for me personally to sit in while I…. recovered. Your under-regions take a beating with labor! With my second I got to a point where I didn’t need it at all, but I totally recommend this, especially for first-time moms!
2. Thin Changing Mat (below)- Me and Reese were on the go, and as I mentioned above… she was a blowout baby. We did a ton of diaper changes all over this county. Many of them in the backseat as I rapidly changed her before walking into a dinner or party. The Gathre (formerly Let’s Playground) Micro is $20 and worth every penny. I’m gonna buy a new one for this baby, because it’s no exaggeration to say that I have used it every single day for 21 months (and it still looks brand new!!!). Small, durable, sanitary, cute. Get one.
   1. Jessica’s Note: Both of my SkipHop diaper bags came with a changing mat and it was a LIFESAVER during those first few newborn months.
3. Velcro Swaddle – I know some people think “Well I can just use a regular swaddle right?” and like, yeah, you can. But I’m telling you that I believe in my bones a big part of why Reese crushed it in the sleep department was our sleep setup – based around velcro swaddles. There are a ton of kinds, and but used and loved this exact set. She couldn’t fight her feet or hands out and she always slept like a champion in them.
   1. Jessica’s Note: My own kids both hated being swaddled with a fiery burning passion. I pushed swaddling for ages before I finally gave in, but we did get Livvy a blanket sleeper from Ikea, just to keep her warm at night. It was loose enough that she didn’t seem to mind it.
4. Wubbanub – (above) I’ve sung the praises of Wubbanub binkies many times before, and I ain’t stoppin now. Here we are, 21 months later, and just barely did I break Reese’s bear and lost her cat – but her dinosaur (Sarah lol) is going strong. Worth. It. As a tiny baby it stays put on their chest when they spit it out. When they get a little bigger they have something to hold. Eventually it makes it so easy for them to learn to grab it and put it back in their mouth. Not to mention they are so much easier to find/more difficult to lose. We’re picking out new ones for baby Holdy soon!
   1. Jessica’s Note: One day I’ll have a baby who does me the courtesy of actually using a binky. When that day happens, this is the first one I’m trying out. Until then, I can only dream!
5. Stroller – I’m gonna talk a little more about strollers because I can attribute a lot of my happiness and postpartum weight loss to LOVING mine. If you don’t love your stroller you’re not going to use it. In fact, you might actively try NOT to use it. I knew I wanted something light and functional. Don’t need lots of bells and whistles, off-roading, storage space, multiples, whatever. I wanted it to be easy to pop up and down – like 5 seconds easy – or else I’d never want to use it. I wanted it work with her car seat and grow with us into toddlerhood.We ended up going with the Uppababy Cruz and Mesa, and I FREAKING LOVE IT. We’re gonna size up to the double (Vista) at some point for baby Holdy #2. It’s hard to know what you will want, but do your best to picture your life when baby gets here. Do you jog? Go to the mall/Target a lot? Walk outside? Travel? Have multiple kids? Pick a few things that are important to you, then watch a shiz ton of Youtube videos, ask your friends what they like/don’t like about theirs, and try out strollers at baby stores where possible. Having a stroller that works for your lifestyle makes a huge difference. I loved never feeling weighed down or like “Ugh I don’t want to have to haul out the stroller…” Instead it was like “Oooh I’m feeling a Target run! Let’s go bb girl!” and 5 seconds later I’m cruising in the doors with Reese still napping after a seamless transfer from car to stroller. It worked for me. Magic. You don’t need the most expensive stroller on the market. Just find one you think will best meet your needs and then get well acquainted with it before baby comes.

Unnecessary

1. Owlet – I’m sure a bunch of people love these, but I can’t help but think they’re just feeding on the fears of new and stressed moms. It doesn’t help that literally all of the posts I’ve seen have been sponsored. Listen to me: You do not need a $250 monitor to tell you your baby is breathing/not breathing. If you want one and have $250 to blow – go for it. But don’t ever feel like your kid is going to stop breathing and it’s your fault if you don’t buy one of these. Read about SIDS, do your best to follow the preventative guidelines, and talk to someone if you still can’t sleep/relax/feel ok.
   1. Jessica’s Note: Girl, preach. The one reason I can see this being valuable is if your baby was born with complications, but unless that’s the case, I too feel like it adds unnecessary stress!
2. Baby Monitor – We didn’t use ours until Reese was like 10 months old, and even then we only used it for a little while. If you need to leave your baby in a room on the opposite side of the house frequently – ok, maybe you need one. But for the most part you don’t need them at all! Crack their door! Or at least not until they’re big enough to actually cause some trouble. Just my opinion.
   1. Jessica’s Note: We’ve never used a baby monitor until our current place had Vivint installed already with a baby monitor included. It’s not worth purchasing, especially if you have a small house. Trust me, you’ll hear your baby cry.
3. A Nursery – Jess hit on this already, but seriously… they don’t need it. They don’t need cute decorations or coordinated bedding crib sets or a plush glider or trendy stuffed animals to display – or even a room at all! Yeah it’s a lot of fun to set up a nursery! Go for it! But if you’re tight honestly this should be the first thing to go. You can keep all their stuff in like 2 drawers of your dresser or a couple of bins in your closet. A crib/bassinet can go in your room (it will anyway for a few months!), or a closet, or an office!
4. Name Brand Clothes – A couple of nice things per size is a good idea, but ask yourself “Do I want to scrub poop out of this 37 times? Do I want this to get completely ruined after 2 wears?” Those are chances you have to take and it doesn’t bug you near as bad if they’re affordable or semi-disposable clothing options. Sometimes the plain Gerber or cheap Walmart onesies got straight up thrown away because it wasn’t worth it. You can get cute stuff at Target, Old Navy, even Walmart, or secondhand and not feel bad if it gets ruined.
   1. Jessica’s Note: My rule of thumb is that the more expensive the clothing item is, the higher the chances the baby will ruin it. Cheap is best! Along with name brand clothing… unless your baby starts showing signs of a rash, you’re probably good to forgo the all-organic cotton clothes. Also, I highly recommend not buying anything white/cream. I guarantee the worst blowouts will happen when they’re wearing white.
5. Fancy Baby Cosmetics – Obviously if organic or whatever products are your battlefield then by all means go for it. But your baby does not need $30 lotion because a celebrity says so. Johnson & Johnson rocks. H*ll, the Smith’s grocery brand of baby lotion rocks!

Of course our lists for things we love and things we didn’t love/need could go on and on and on. And we’d love to talk more about it, maybe over some Chipotle? Let us know.